Best Crib Mattress Reviews and Buying Guide

As a parent, you want the best crib mattress for your baby. But as you know, finding the best model will inevitably mean going through tons of crib mattress reviews in order to find the perfect mattress.

Unfortunately, this kind of research takes numerous hours, and as a soon-to-be mother, who has that kind of time?

Well, I have some great news. If you want to find the best crib mattress for your baby, all you need to do is read this guide.

I’ve read the top reviews of all kinds of crib mattresses or used them myself. And from there, I’ve come up with a complete and comprehensive list of the very best baby mattresses plus lots of additional helpful information.

Check it out to find the perfect mattress for you!

Our Top 10 Best Crib Mattresses Comparison Chart

Types of Crib Mattresses

The best mattress for babies is one that is safe, comfortable and long-lasting. But within this framework, there are a number of mattress types available.

The following is a list of the different types of mattresses that you can choose from for your baby.

  • Innerspring Mattresses

Innerspring mattresses are those that have steel coils inside them. The coils are covered with padding made out of foam and fabric. Spring mattresses tend to be firmer and longer lasting than other types of mattresses.

  • Foam Mattresses

Foam mattresses are lightweight and made of between three and 6 inches of synthetic foam. Make sure that you find a foam mattress that has an adequate firmness. Mattresses that are too soft can sink under the weight of a baby and may cause a risk of SIDS.

  • Organic Mattresses

Organic mattresses are made of natural, organic materials. These may be materials like plant-based foam, natural latex, wool, cotton or coconut fibers. Sometimes, these mattresses also have springs in them.

  • Breathable Mattresses

Finally, breathable mattresses are a new product. These mattresses are made of materials that ostensibly allow freer breathing for your baby.

Best Organic Crib Mattress Reviews

1. LA Baby Natural IV Triple Zone 2 in 1 Soy Foam Crib MattressLA Baby Natural IV Triple Zone 2 in 1 Best Soy Foam Crib Mattress

The absolute best organic crib mattress on the market is the LA Baby Natural IV Triple Zone 2 in 1 Soy Foam Crib Mattress. The core of this mattress is made of high density soy foam. It has soy foam borders as well, which offer extra safety and support.

All of the products in this mattress are made from renewable resources, and it is known widely as the best non toxic crib mattress out there. Not only will this mattress put your mind at ease where your baby’s health and safety are concerned, but it’s also extra comfortable!

2. Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler MattressPhoto of the Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress

If you’re looking for a slightly cheaper organic mattress, the Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress is the best organic baby mattress in this realm. This mattress has springs instead of memory foam, which can offer a cushier feel for your baby. Naturally, the mattress is non-toxic and passes Green Gold and all other safety and healthy standards with flying colors.

How To Choose a Good Crib Mattress

You want the best crib mattress for your baby, but how do you go about rating each option if you’ve never purchased a baby mattress before? In general, you’ve just got to know what to look for.

Photo of a baby in a small cribHere are the most important factors to consider when shopping for the best rated baby mattress.

  • The Exact Size for Your Particular Crib

Crib mattresses must fit the width and length of your crib exactly. You will probably buy your crib first, so take measurements, and make sure that the mattresses you’re considering would fit snug inside.

  • Safety Certifications

The best mattress for cribs of any kind meet all national safety standards. Look for mattresses that are CPSC, ASTM and JPMA certified.

  • The Optimal Firmness

You want the best sleep for your child, so look for a comfortable firmness. In addition, make sure that the mattress is not too soft, or this may put your child at risk for SIDS

  • A Moderate Weight

The best baby crib mattresses aren’t too heavy or too light. Mattresses that are super light tend to not be well-made, but those that are too heavy can be a pain to move.

  • Quality Ticking

Accidents can happen, so make sure that the ticking or cover on your mattress is double or triple laminated and reinforced with nylon for optimal water resistance.

  • High Density

The density of the mattress should be firm. Foam mattresses will list the density in the speculations. If you want a coil mattress, look for those with a gauge of 15.5 or lower and 135 or more coils.

  • Good Bounce Back or ResiliencyPhoto of a baby crib and a teddy bear

You want your baby’s mattress to have a good resiliency. This means that when you put your hand down on the mattress, the foam or padding regains its shape quickly.

  • Easy Cleaning

The best mattresses are easy to clean. Ideally, your mattress will come with a cover that can be put in the washing machine when necessary.

  • Venting

Air flow is important for your baby’s sleep. Small holes in the mattress sides can help facilitate this and may be beneficial for your baby’s breathing.

  • A Moderate Price

Finally, if you and your partner are on a budget, make sure to consider the price of the mattress when shopping.

Top 10 Best Crib Mattresses

1. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib MattressSafety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

  • Super long-lasting and overall, the best crib mattress for newborns
  • Comes with easy to clean and waterproof vinyl cover
  • Firm support provided by thermo-bonded fiber core
  • Some crib mattress reviews for this mattress were not happy that this mattress was a bit short for some crib sizes. Always measure your crib before purchasing a new mattress for it.

For my money and in the opinions of many baby specialists, the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is the best crib mattress on the market.

Even though it’s true that a few of the baby mattress reviews mention that this model may be too short for some cribs, it will fit snugly inside a number of standard-sized cribs and make for a great bed for your baby.

Overall Value for the Money

As the best baby crib mattress on this list, the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is definitely worth the money. Not only is it well made and super comfortable for your baby, but it’s being sold at an amazing price.

2. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Crib & Toddler MattressDelta Children Twinkle Stars Crib & Toddler Mattress

  • Firmness provided by polyester, thermo-bonded fiber core
  • Secure fit in mattress provided by square corners
  • Comes with laminated vinyl cover for easy cleaning
  • Exceeds or meets all safety standards
  • Some users found that the mattress made a lot of noise when their children were in their cribs and on the mattress moving about.

The Delta Children Twinkle Stars Crib & Toddler Mattress is another one of the best baby mattresses and second on my top 10 list. Use this mattress in a crib, or I have always liked it as the best mattress for toddler bed use. If you’re looking to save money, simply use it as both!

Overall Value for the Money

I’ve owned this mattress and loved it. Again, the Delta Children Twinkle Stars Crib & Toddler Mattress is the best toddler mattress that I know of. I’ve known many kids who’ve loved sleeping on it when they were toddlers, they would fall asleep as soon as their heads hit the pillow. It’s sold at a reasonable price, and I highly recommend it.

3. Dream On Me 5″ Mini Crib MattressDream On Me5" Spring Coil Best Portable Crib Mattress

  • Antibacterial, hypoallergenic and resistant to mildew and mold of any kind
  • Meets and exceeds all safety and health tests
  • Firm support provided by interwoven steel coils
  • Made in the USA
  • Select crib mattress reviews mention that this mattress may be too small for some cribs. Always measure your crib before purchasing a mattress to make sure that it will fit snugly.

The Dream On Me 5″ Mini Crib Mattress is another of the best crib mattresses on the market. Naturally, because it’s a mini mattress, it’s going to be on the small side. This is a mattress that is meant for use with portable cribs, so check your measurements.

Overall Value for the Money

The Dream On Me 5″ Mini Crib Mattress is super affordable and has a great design. This mattress can fit most types of portable cribs. I love that it’s safe and has passed all of the necessary certifications.

4. My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib MattressMy First Premium Memory Foam Baby Crib Mattress

  • Cover is waterproof and can be easily removed and washed when necessary
  • Meets and exceeds all health and safety certifications and standards
  • Hypoallergenic mattress is resistant to microbes, mildew and mold
  • Lead and phthalate free
  • Select reviews mention that this mattress is soft and not firm enough for some babies’ preferences.

The My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib Mattress is the best mattress for crib use and especially the best foam crib mattress. The square corners help it to be even more durable and safe for your baby. All quality standards and certifications are met with this product.

Overall Value for the Money

As the best foam crib mattress, the My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib Mattress is a favorite that I always give as an example of a high quality product. The cost is slightly higher than other models, but you’re getting a quality memory foam mattress here, and I highly recommend it.

5. Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib MattressMilliard Hypoallergenic Best Baby Crib Mattress

  • Mattress is reinforced with waterproofing on the sides and top, but the bottom allows for air flow
  • Offers top quality comfort for your baby
  • Made with all anti-flame materials and absolutely no chemicals
  • More than one crib mattress review mentioned that the cover is not completely waterproof, and you may want to add another waterproof protective sheet with it to be sure that accidents don’t leak through.

With the Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress, we have the best infant mattress for those babies who may be prone to allergies or common colds. Some parents said that the cover was not completely waterproof, but naturally, you should always double layer with a mattress pad too.

Overall Value for the Money

Not only is the Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress the best baby mattress for those babies with allergies, but it’s also the best mattress in terms of style. I love the cute polka dots on this cover! The price is reasonable, and this is a great find.

6. Moonlight Slumber Little DreamerMoonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness Best Crib Mattress

  • Cover is polyethylene and PVC free as well as free of lead and phthalates
  • Cover is waterproofed with non-toxic materials
  • Seams are side stitched
  • Comes with treatment of antimicrobial protection
  • Made in the USA
  • This mattress is more expensive than many of the others, so if you’re on a budget, you may want to consider looking elsewhere.
  • Some baby mattress reviews lamented that a free sheet was not included with this mattress as is often the standard practice.

If you’re little one likes a firm mattress or if you’re hyper aware of the need for a firm sleeping surface because of the risk of SIDS, the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer is the top notch crib mattress. It is also non-toxic and has CertiPUR certification.

Overall Value for the Money

Again, the best crib mattress for baby safety in terms of SIDS is the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer. It’s definitely one of the firmest mattresses on the market. The only thing that I don’t like about this mattress is that it’s pricey. But if money is not a serious issue for you, this is a great buy.

7. Kolcraft Pure Sleep TherapeuticKolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Crib Mattress

  • Firm support is provided by 150 heavy gauge steel coils
  • Cover is lock-stitched waterproof and resistant to mildew, moisture and stains
  • GREENGUARD Children and Schools certified
  • Meets or exceeds all health and safety standards
  • A slight odor was a problem listed in some Kolcraft crib mattress reviews, but keep in mind that this odor usually goes away after leaving the mattress out in open air for several hours.

The Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic is a 150 heavy gauge steel coil mattress. It offers super firm support for your baby to keep them comfortable and protect against SIDS. If you’re looking for the best baby bed mattress with coils, this is it.

Overall Value for the Money

The price on the Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic is extremely reasonable. Most of the best baby mattress options that have coils in them tend to be more expensive, so this is a rare find.

8. Milliard Crib Mattress, Dual Comfort SystemMilliard Crib Mattress Dual Comfort System

  • Excellent mattress for newborns, babies and toddlers alike
  • CertiPUR-US certified foam
  • Can be used two ways for two types of comfort for your baby or toddler
  • Some of the best crib mattress reviews found that the mattress had a slight odor when they opened the package. This is common with some products like mattresses, and the odor tends to go away after leaving the product in open air for a few hours.

The Milliard Crib Mattress, Dual Comfort System best mattress for baby use and toddler use. I love that you can flip this mattress over as your child grows. Toddlers tend to like a softer sleeping surface, so flipping it to the soft side when your child gets older makes great sense.

Overall Value for the Money

If you need a quality sleep solution for a baby and a toddler, the Milliard Crib Mattress, Dual Comfort System is perfect. Keep in mind that the price is slightly higher, but you’re technically getting two mattresses for the price of one!

9. Simmons Kids Beautyrest BeginningsSimmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe

  • Even support and comfort provided by 231 luxury pocketed coil springs
  • Extra safety and stability is provided by Innofoam corner protectors and reinforced border protection
  • Cover is woven and completely resistant to stains and water or liquid of any kind
  • Some crib mattresses reviews mentioned seam stitching loosening after using the mattress for some time.
  • The mattress is extremely firm and may not be comfortable for some children.

Some of the best baby mattress reviews for the Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings mattress said that seams were loosening after a few month’s of use, but I’ve found this to be one of the best firm crib mattress even still. I’ve had this mattress myself, and don’t agree with the crib mattress reviews that said the stitches were loosening. This was not a problem for me.

Overall Value for the Money

If you want best mattress for baby crib use that has coils and you weren’t happy with the Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic, try the Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings. This mattress is more expensive, but it’s well made with 231 luxury pocketed coil springs and can offer a great sleep for your baby.

10. Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler MattressNewton Crib Mattress Best Toddler Mattress

  • Does not contain latex, rubber, allergens or glue
  • Extremely comfortable for newborns and babies
  • Breathable design offers great air circulation throughout the mattress, which offers the best sleep for your baby
  • This is definitely a more expensive mattress for children that will only use it for a few years.
  • The polyester and plastic cover may not suit all babies’ skin.
  • Some crib mattress review write-ups mentioned that one side of the mattress may develop a dip over time.

Finally, we have the Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler Mattress. This is an alternative choice for the best toddler bed mattress. I love how breathable this model is. If mildew or mold are problems in your home, this super comfortable mattress is wonderful for your baby. It’s even washable!

Overall Value for the Money

I love the Newton Crib Mattress & Toddler Mattress. It’s definitely one of the absolute best toddler mattresses on the market. With that being said, this is a pricey product, so make sure that you read the price tag clearly before buying it.

Don’t Forget a Good Mattress Pad

Parents are always seeking the best ways to keep their babies healthy, happy and comfortable. And this means providing them with the best possible sleep.

All of this starts with finding the best baby mattress, and as we know, this can take a lot of research and shopping around. But there’s more to a good sleep for your baby than a good mattress, and this is where mattress pads come in.

Even the best mattress for baby crib use needs a quality mattress pad to go over it.

Why You Need a Mattress Pad

American Pillowcase Crib Mattress Protector Which is fully WaterproofThere are a number of reasons why a mattress pad can be beneficial for your baby when they’re sleeping. First, crib mattresses tend to be quite thin and flat. This means that they often need some extra cushioning. A mattress pad can provide both warmth and extra comfort.

Next, mattress pads can act like protective covers for your mattress. After all, mattresses themselves are much more expensive than mattress pads, so protecting your mattress from spills and accidents is essential. This protection can also keep bacterial growth on the mattress at bay.

How To Choose a Mattress Pad

Be sure to make the following considerations when you purchase your new mattress pad.

  • a) Avoid mattress pads that are on the thick side.

The thicker bulk could put children at risk for sudden infant death syndrome. or SIDS.

  • b) Pick a quality material.

Look for natural, organic materials like rubberized cotton, wool or polyester.

  • c) The fit of the mattress pad around the mattress must be perfect.

This is important because if the pad does not fit tightly, extra fabric could suffocate a child.

  • d) Make sure that your mattress pad is resistant to flames.

You need a flame-resistant mattress pad, but never choose one with PBDEs, a common flame-resistant chemical. This is a toxin.

  • e) Find a water resistant mattress pad.

The purpose of keeping spills and accidents from leaking through will be lost if your mattress pad isn’t water resistant.

Best Mattress Pads

According to the top baby crib mattress reviews, the following are four mattress pads that work great for the best crib mattresses.

1. Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad ProtectorKiddleCo Waterproof Best Crib Mattress Pad Protector

The Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad Protector is made of polyester and bamboo rayon. This mattress pad is breathable, yet waterproof, so it easily protects against spills and accidents. It’s even stain resistant.

The material on this mattress pad is super soft, and the fabric is all organic, which is why many organic crib mattress reviews recommend this product. Caring for the pad is easy as well. It’s simple to put it on your mattress or take it off. When you need to, you can throw it in your washing machine. It can even be put in the dryer on a low setting, so you want have to wait for it to air dry.

The Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad Protector provides the perfect fit for mattress pads that are 28 by 52 inches. This pad fits mattresses also has extra deep pockets from 7 to 9 inches. The pad is white.

2. PharMeDoc Waterproof Mattress Bed ProtectorPharMeDoc Best Waterproof Mattress Bed Protector

For little ones who are on their way out of the crib and into their own beds, the best baby mattress reviews rave about the PharMeDoc Waterproof Mattress Bed Protector.

This bed protector is the perfect bedwetting solution. The pad goes over top of the mattress where the child will lay. It is extra thick and can absorb up to 8 cups of liquid. The quilted cotton on top of polyester and rayon offers layered protection so that nothing will get through this pad.

Washing the pad is easy as well. It can be thrown into the washing machine and dried in the dryer on a low setting. Even after washing, this mattress pad will retain its shape and absorbency.

3. PUREgrace Crib Mattress PadPUREgrace Hypoallergenic Waterproof Soft Tencel

The PUREgrace Crib Mattress Pad is one of the best baby mattress pads on the market for crib use. The cover is made of 100 percent natural tencel. Tencel is a combination of eucalyptus based fibers that are grown free of herbicides and pesticides. This offers a luxurious, comfortable surface for your baby to sleep on. Tencel is naturally hypoallergenic as well.

Putting this cover on your mattress is simple with the deep pocketed corners that are also reinforced for additional safety. Taking the mattress off is just as easy, and it’s no problem to throw this pad in the washing machine when you need to. The pad can even be dried in the dryer on a low setting.

4. Organic Crib Mattress Cover PadPhoto of the Best Organic Crib Mattress Cover Pad

Finally, organic baby mattress reviews always recommend the Organic Crib Mattress Cover Pad. This mattress pad is made of super soft organic bamboo. This organic material offers a non-irritating touch for any baby’s soft skin. It is also hypoallergenic and antibacterial.

At the same time that this mattress pad is soft and organic, it is also long-lasting and durable. The waterproof properties on this mattress pad will wick away any liquid, and clean up is a breeze.

Remove the Old Mattress the Right Way

If you’re ready to get rid of an old mattress in order to purchase a new one, make sure that you do this the correct way. Don’t simply throw your old mattress into the garbage or leave it on the curb. Instead, allow professionals to do the job for you.

In fact, a wonderful mattress removal service is available from Amazon. This service can come to your house and remove your old mattress for you. The mattress will then go to charity, or if you prefer, it can be disposed of properly.

Check with Amazon Home Services to see if your area can be provided this service.

Also Consider Getting a Cover

In addition to mattress pads themselves, there are also mattress pad covers that can help protect both your mattress and your mattress pad. Most mattress pad covers are waterproof to prevent accidents from leaking through to the mattress pad and the mattress.

Mattress pad covers come in many styles, but I like the following ACC Pack N Play Crib Mattress Pad Cover.

ACC Pack N Play Crib Mattress Pad CoverPhoto of the ACC Pack N Play Crib Mattress Pad Cover

The ACC Pack N Play Crib Mattress Pad Cover fits snugly around your portable crib mattress and is waterproof to protect it from spills and accidents.

This mattress pad is easy to put on and take off. When it needs to be washed, you can throw it into the washing machine, and you can even dry it in the dryer on a low setting.

Summary and Making the Decision

Photo of a tiny baby in a crib

Photo credit: donnierayjones via Visual Hunt / CC BY

The safety and comfort of your child is of the utmost importance, and both of these factors should be especially heavily considered when searching for the best crib mattress.

Earlier on, I’ve provided you with a list of the most recommended baby cribs, so it was only right to write about best rated crib mattress options above. All of these mattresses have been chosen based on the professional crib mattress reviews that I have read through. Now, the rest of the work is up to you.

I know it can be overwhelming to read through all of these reviews and try to make up your mind. But ultimately, it just comes down to making your best educated guess.

If you’re truly having a difficult time narrowing your search, I recommend picking your three favorite mattresses, and making a list of your own pros and cons for each of them. Weigh the different factors based on your unique preferences.

In the end, you should be able to single out one mattress that you like best. All you need to do from there is buy it!

Finding the right crib for your child can be a difficult task. But in many ways, finding the best baby crib mattress is even more important. Good luck on your search!